COVID-19 Info  COVID Dashboard


After a two-month investigation, the Northern Colorado Drug Task Force (NCDTF) arrested seven people and recovered distribution amounts of fentanyl and methamphetamines from a Fort Collins home.

On February 17, 2023, the NCDTF served two high-risk search warrants in the 2500 block of South Shields Street in Fort Collins. The operation was conducted by the Fort Collins Police Services Patrol division and FCPS SWAT team with assistance from the Larimer County Sheriff’s Office All Hazards/Crisis Response team, LCSO Reserves, and LCSO Jail Transport. Investigators recovered distribution amounts of dangerous drugs, stolen property, and counterfeit currency. Seven individuals were taken into custody during this operation:

  • Shantelle Garcia (081291): Warrant arrest (2 felony, 1 misdemeanor)
  • Amy Semonchick (071080): Warrant arrest (4 felony, 1 misdemeanor)
  • Mathew Whyte (010493): Warrant arrest (3 misdemeanors)
  • Michael Pusey-Fendler (090687): Warrant arrest (1 felony, 1 misdemeanor), Unlawful Possession of Drugs – Methamphetamine (DF4)
  • Brandon Eastin (062891): Criminal Possession of Two or More Financial Devices (F6), Criminal Possession of Identification Documents (M2), Unlawful Possession of Drugs – Methamphetamine (DF4)
  • Talon Glover (012693): Warrant arrest (1 felony, 1 misdemeanor)
  • Jeremy Scott (041498): Warrant arrest (3 misdemeanors), Resisting Arrest (M2), Obstructing a Peace Officer (M2), Introducing Contraband in the Second Degree (F6), Unlawful Possession of Drugs – Fentanyl (DM1), Possession of Drug Paraphernalia (DPO)

The investigation is ongoing. Anyone with information is encouraged to contact the NCDTF Drug Tip Hotline at 970-416-2560. Tipsters can remain anonymous.

Booking photos are attached. Bond was not set at the time of this release. The charges are merely an accusation, and the defendant is presumed innocent until, and unless, proven guilty.

The NCDTF thanks all of our member agencies and partners who continue working to make our community safer, including:

Larimer County Sheriff's Office
Fort Collins Police Services
Loveland Police Department
Windsor Police Department
Eighth Judicial District Attorney's Office
Colorado Adult Parole
Drug Enforcement Administration

Click a photo to enlarge.

Published on: 
Friday, February 17, 2023 - 5:29pm
Contact Details: 

Public Information Officer
Larimer County Sheriff's Office
(970)980-2501 |  Email

I Want To

Larimer County, Colorado

200 W. Oak Street
Fort Collins, CO 80521
Map of Facilities

Connect with Us

Larimer County on Facebook Larimer County on Twitter Larimer County on YouTube Larimer County on LinkedIn Instagram
Email Subscriptions
Transparency | Accessibility | Security
Legal Disclaimers
Website Feedback Weather Forecast & Alerts
Flag Status:   US FlagFullColorado FlagFull
up arrow